PropLens · Deal Sheet

14-20 Airlie Street, Alyth, Perth and Kinross, PH11 8AJ

Retail 750 sqft (assumed) Freehold (assumed) · Fair
Asking
£50,000
View on LoopNet
Offer range · Operational reposition (near-term vacant)
Cash only
£25,000
Not lendable at 65% LTV VP ceiling (yield-anchored)

Net cash flow at the assumed NIA (750 sqft) and ERV (£6,375) is too thin once debt service is paid. Not lendable at standard 65% LTV. The £50,000 asking price is below the conventional commercial mortgage minimum (£100,000 floor for most lenders); cash purchase or SSAS-funded acquisition is the indicated path.

Not lendable at standard 65% LTV. DSCR 4.90× and Debt Yield 39.2% sit in the Avoid band on the assumed NIA. The deal works only as a cash purchase, SSAS-funded acquisition, or with a substantially higher confirmed NIA / passing rent than assumed here.

Income basis Property described as let café investment with vacant possession from December 2026; passing rent not disclosed in card data. Income basis is ERV from rural Scottish retail comparables (750 sqft × £8.50/sqft Fair-adjusted). Year 1 effective cash-on-cash will be lower depending on lease-up speed after the existing tenancy ends.
£6,375 ERV £0 (FRI assumed) NOI £6,375

Lender lens · static (cash purchase basis)

Five ratios at asking price £50,000 (no debt assumed)

DSCR @ 8% raten/aNot lendable
Stress DSCR @ 10% raten/aNot lendable
Debt Yield (NOI / Loan)39.2%Strong
Yield on Cost (cash all-in)6.7%Avoid
Net Initial Yield (NOI / asking)12.8%Strong

Cash purchase: 0% LTV · NOI £6,375 (ERV from rural Scottish retail comparables, condition adjusted Fair) · All-in £95,500

Thesis

14-20 Airlie Street is a ground-floor retail unit in central Alyth, a small Perth and Kinross village (population approximately 2,300). The property is currently let as a café with vacant possession available from December 2026, eligible for 100% Small Business Bonus rates relief, and asking £50,000. At this lot size the deal sits below the typical conventional commercial mortgage minimum (£100,000 floor), so the practical acquisition route is cash purchase or SSAS-funded acquisition rather than leveraged debt. ERV on the assumed 750 sqft NIA at rural Scottish retail rates of c. £8.50/sqft gives an annual rental of c. £6,375 and a stabilised VP of £25,000 at a 14.75% ARY. Asking £50,000 sits above the VP ceiling.

What's wrong with it
  • Lot size £50,000 sits below the typical conventional commercial mortgage minimum (£100,000 floor at OakNorth, Hampshire Trust, Shawbrook and similar specialist lenders).
  • Listing NIA of 11,706 sqft refers to the whole terrace building or parcel rather than the ground-floor unit; actual NIA is not stated and materially affects every calculation below.
  • Alyth is a rural Scottish village with thin retail tenant demand; void on the existing tenant's exit could exceed the 12-month default assumption.
What's right with it
  • Currently let with passing income (figure not disclosed), giving evidence of operating café demand at this address.
  • 100% Small Business Bonus relief eligibility removes rates liability for the next occupier, supporting the affordability of village-scale retail businesses.
  • Period stone building with prominent painted façade, large glazed frontage, direct street access, and outdoor seating space — physical attributes a small café or destination retail tenant would value.
Risks
  • Vacant possession from December 2026 transfers re-let risk to the buyer; Alyth's tertiary tenant pool may extend the void beyond the 12-month default.
  • Passing rent not disclosed in card data. If actual passing rent is materially below the ERV used here (£6,375), the deal economics deteriorate further.
  • Three-storey terraced building with residential accommodation above implies shared services or party walls; investigate ownership of upper floors and any service charge or repair obligation.
DD gaps
  • Confirm the ground-floor unit NIA (assumed 750 sqft here) and clarify what the listing's 11,706 sqft figure references.
  • Obtain current lease, passing rent, lease length, FRI / IRI basis, and confirm December 2026 expiry / break.
  • Confirm title boundary (whether the residential accommodation above is included or excluded from the sale) and any shared service or party wall obligations.
Considerations
  • Sub-£100,000 lot size narrows the lender field substantially. Cash purchase or SSAS-funded acquisition are the practical routes.
  • SSAS eligibility holds for the commercial use class. Holding within a pension wrapper removes income tax and capital gains exposure for the duration of ownership.
  • Possible inclusion in the Alyth Conservation Area; period stone terrace suggests possible Cat C listing. Internal cosmetic works generally do not trigger LBC; signage, frontage or external alterations would.

Property & Valuation

Facts, condition, comparables, valuation stack, and purchase-cost schedule for due-diligence reference.

Facts

Address14-20 Airlie Street, Alyth, Perth and Kinross, PH11 8AJ
Asking price£50,000
Property typeRetail
NIA (assumed)750 sqft Listing quotes 11,706 sqft, which represents the whole three-storey terrace building or parcel; the ground floor café unit being sold is assumed at 750 sqft NIA pending brochure confirmation.
TenureFreehold (assumed)
Condition ratingFair
PortalLoopNet
JurisdictionScotland
TenancyLet café investment; VP available from December 2026; passing rent not disclosed in card data
Rates100% Small Business Bonus relief eligible
AgentsSadik Chowdhury, Leigh Porteous
ListingView on LoopNet

Photos

Physical assessment

  • Exterior: three-storey traditional stone-built terraced building under a pitched slate roof. Painted façade with large glazed frontage and direct street access.
  • Frontage: large glazed shopfront; raised planter boxes; outdoor seating space to the front.
  • Interior: ground floor in retail and commercial use; layout details not provided in listing.
  • Upper floors: residential accommodation above. Ownership and inclusion in the sale not stated.
  • Condition: rated Fair from listing text (no "refurbished" trigger; period building described in standard terms).
  • Surroundings: mixed-use commercial parade in Alyth village centre; established local businesses and limited footfall typical for a rural Scottish village.

Per-unit income

LineCalcValue
ERV (rural Scottish retail comparable)750 sqft × £8.50/sqft (£10 base × 0.85 Fair condition)£6,375
Assumed landlord costs (FRI)Insurance recharged; tenant responsible for repairs£0
NOI£6,375
Passing rent (from listing)Figure not disclosed in card datan/a

Yield selection

SectorRetail, rural Scottish village (tertiary)
Neighbourhood retail tertiary range13%+ (yield-selection-guide)
Midpoint13.0%
Sub-£500k lot premium+175 bps
ARY (rounded to nearest 25 bps)14.75%
Term yield (ARY − 75 bps)14.00%
Reversion yield14.75%
Sensitivity (NOI £6,375)Value
13.75%£46,364
14.75% (selected)£43,220
15.75%£40,476

Valuation stack

BasisMethodValue
Rack Rent (gross ceiling)ERV £6,375 ÷ 14.75%£43,220
VP (MV3, vacant single-let)Rack less 12mo void, 6mo rent-free, 10% reletting, 18mo holding£25,000
180-day restricted marketingVP × 0.90£22,500
90-day restricted marketingVP × 0.80£20,000
Asking£50,000

T&R is not calculated because the property reverts to vacant in December 2026 and passing rent is not disclosed. Multi-let is not applicable: Alyth is not covered in PropLens multi-let data and the building footprint is too small for the 3+ unit threshold.

Acquisition benchmark

Alyth is not listed in acquisition-benchmarks.md and is not covered in the Edozo retail rates table. Asking £67/sqft (£50,000 ÷ 750 sqft assumed) is the property-specific reference. For rural Scottish village retail, sub-£100/sqft asking is consistent with the secondary-to-tertiary band.

Purchase costs

ItemCalcValue
LBTT (commercial Scotland)£50,000 (below £150k threshold)£0
Legal feesStandard£4,500
DisbursementsSearches, registrations£650
Broker fee1% of purchase£500
Lender arrangement (if applicable)2% of 65% LTV loan£650
Lender legal (if applicable)Standard£2,500
Surveys / DDBuilding survey, valuation£2,000
Total purchase costs (at asking)21.6% of price£10,800
Refurb to let750 sqft × £50/sqft × 1.12 rural premium£42,000
All-in at asking £50,000£102,800

For a cash purchase the lender arrangement and lender legal lines fall away (saving c. £3,150), reducing total costs to c. £7,650.

Strategy & Appraisal

Value-add angles, holding-structure recommendation, and supporting analyses for the bid thesis.

Value-add angles

Cash purchase, refurb-to-let (single tenant)
Moderate

At £50,000 all-in cash with c. £42,000 of refurb plus c. £7,650 of cash-purchase costs, the total commitment is c. £99,650. Stabilised NOI of £6,375 gives a Yield on Cost of c. 6.4%. Comparable to or above PropCo income hurdles for cash buyers.

Max purchase (yield-anchored at VP): £25,000. Key risk: re-let void on Dec 2026 expiry in a thin Alyth tenant market.

SSAS commercial hold
Moderate

Office / retail commercial use qualifies for SSAS ownership with 0% tax on rent and gains. SSAS lender minimums typically £100k+, so the practical SSAS route is cash from scheme assets rather than SSAS borrowing. At £50,000 cash the rent of £6,375 clears the lot and produces a stable tax-free yield within the pension wrapper.

Max purchase (cash SSAS): £25,000. Key risk: SSAS administration costs (£2k-£5k/year) erode the tax benefit on small lots; absolute income tax saving is modest at this NOI level.

Alternative use — change to residential
Weak

Ground floor unit could be converted to a single residential dwelling (subject to Perth and Kinross consent). Rural Scottish 1-bed conversion comparable sale price c. £80,000-£120,000 on village markets; conversion cost £100/sqft commercial-to-resi (rural premium adjusted) plus separation works puts net residual close to the asking price. Tight or negative margin without committed grant funding.

Max purchase (residual): close to asking, marginal. Key risk: change of use consent in conservation area; rural resi resale market is illiquid.

Conventional 65% LTV leveraged hold
Weak

Lot size £50,000 sits below the typical commercial lender minimum (£100,000 floor at specialist lenders OakNorth, Hampshire Trust, Shawbrook). Even where a lender entertains the lot, the resulting £32,500 loan produces debt service that absorbs c. 20% of NOI.

Max purchase (conventional leverage): not lendable. Key risk: no lender appetite for the lot size at standard 65% LTV.

Holding structure

Recommended structure is cash purchase via SSAS if pension assets allow, otherwise personal name or SPV with no debt. The commercial use class qualifies the property for SSAS ownership with full tax exemption on rental income and capital gains. SSAS borrowing is impractical at this lot size given typical £100,000 lender minimums. Personal-name cash purchase remains an alternative for investors without SSAS infrastructure, with the property treated as a small commercial income asset.

Tags

Alyth
Rural Scotland
Sub-£100k lot
Cash purchase

Sources

  • LoopNet listing for 14-20 Airlie Street, Alyth (property data, asking price, photos, description)
  • PropLens yield-selection-guide: rural / village retail yield range
  • PropLens conversion-costs reference: standard refurb £50/sqft with rural premium +12%
  • Revenue Scotland LBTT non-residential bands (2026-2027 frozen)
  • Scottish Small Business Bonus Scheme: 100% relief threshold for combined RV under £15,000
  • RICS Red Book MV1/MV2/MV3 framework

Jurisdiction

Scotland